
America Creates the World’s First Penitentiary
Clip: Episode 1 | 8m 30sVideo has Closed Captions
The Founding Father Benjamin Rush offers a new form of punishment: the world's first penitentiary.
The Founding Father and reformer Benjamin Rush suggests that public punishments may not be the best way to deter criminals. Instead, he proposed locking away criminals in solitude to reflect and repent for their crimes, leading to the establishment of the Walnut Street Prison and Eastern State Penitentiary, the world's first penitentiaries.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

America Creates the World’s First Penitentiary
Clip: Episode 1 | 8m 30sVideo has Closed Captions
The Founding Father and reformer Benjamin Rush suggests that public punishments may not be the best way to deter criminals. Instead, he proposed locking away criminals in solitude to reflect and repent for their crimes, leading to the establishment of the Walnut Street Prison and Eastern State Penitentiary, the world's first penitentiaries.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Measuring Crime and Punishment
How does the way we collect and measure crime shape our understanding of it? Crime statistics can tell us how crime changes over time. But the way crime is measured, defined, and communicated can also shape public perception and policy.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship♪ Voice: An attachment to kindred and society is one of the strongest feelings in the human heart.
A separation from them, therefore, has ever been considered as one of the severest punishments that can be inflicted upon man.
Personal liberty is so dear to all men that the loss of it for an indefinite time is a punishment so severe that death has often been preferred to it.
Benjamin Rush.
Narrator: Many believed the new nation should develop a more enlightened system of justice, where the punishment would be proportional to the crime.
No American was more concerned with questions of crime and punishment than the Philadelphia reformer Dr.
Benjamin Rush.
A signer of the Declaration of Independence, he was an advocate for women's education and a pioneer in the treatment of mental illness.
He was one of the first Americans to argue that public punishment didn't work.
Voice: The reformation of a criminal can never be effected by a public punishment.
A man who has lost his character at a whipping-post has nothing valuable left to lose.
I shall take the liberty of declaring that public punishments tend to make bad men worse and to increase crimes.
Benjamin Rush.
Caleb Smith: There were huge crowds at these events.
These become scenes of riot and disturbance, and the public's capacities for sympathy get pulled in the wrong ways, things get disordered.
You know, if--to be deterred, I have to identify with the person who did this thing and say, "If I do the same thing he did, I'll be put to death," but I might also start identifying with him in other kinds of ways, right, or the violence itself might be exciting and contagious, and that's why we need to move punishment out of the public square and behind closed doors.
Voice: Let it not be supposed that I wish to abolish punishments.
Far from it.
I wish only to change the place and manner of inflicting them.
Let a large house be erected in a remote part of the state.
Let its doors be of iron and let the grating, occasioned by opening and shutting them, deeply pierce the soul.
Let all the officers of the house be strictly forbidden ever to discover any signs of mirth or even levity in the presence of the criminals.
To increase the horror of this abode of discipline and misery, let it be called by some name that shall import its design, a "house of repentance."
[Benjamin Rush] Narrator: Inspired by Benjamin Rush's idea of a house of repentance, Pennsylvania decided to turn a section of Philadelphia's squalid, overcrowded jail into the Walnut Street Prison.
Other countries had prisons-- the Bastille in France, England's Tower of London-- but they held political prisoners.
The Walnut Street Prison would be something new.
It was to be a place of punishment and penitence for ordinary people who broke the law.
It was the world's first penitentiary.
McLennan: It's not like no one's ever been held against their will before.
It's not like we haven't had workhouses before, but that's to pay off a debt.
What we haven't had before is incarceration as punishment for crime.
Narrator: The Walnut Street Prison opened its doors in 1790.
Most men and women held there were convicted of property crimes.
During the day, they toiled together in workshops so they could learn "habits of industry."
Mangual: The penitentiary represented a real kind of win for reformers in society.
The religious ideal was that everyone has an inherent capacity for redemption that needs to be recognized.
Prisons were actually a humane response to how we were doing justice up until that point.
Manion: It sounds more progressive.
It sounds like an improvement on what was... and then there's the reality.
[Indistinct chatter, footsteps] Voice: I will now give you some information of the general situation of the interior of this penitentiary, so celebrated for its humanity.
The cells are constructed over the common sewer, from which there is a flue leading to each apartment.
That at once accounts for the numerous deaths and ruined constitutions of the unfortunate inhabitants, who for the most trifling fault, are hurried into these abominable receptacles for 30, 60, and 90 days with one miserable blanket for their covering and an allowance of 3 ounces of brown bread for 24 hours.
Ann Carson.
Narrator: Ann Carson, who had been sent to the Walnut Street Prison after being found guilty of robbery, published one of the first accounts of life there.
The penitentiary she described was as squalid as the jail it had replaced.
Many of the prisoners showed no sign of repentance or reform.
They refused to work, gambled, drank, rioted.
Some even managed to escape and terrorize the city.
♪ In 1821, the state of Pennsylvania decided to replace Walnut Street with a massive new prison several miles from the city center, the Eastern State Penitentiary.
It was one of the most expensive public buildings in the nation, and it was built for one lofty goal: helping men and women repent and reform through solitary confinement.
Behind its 30-foot high walls, 7 cell blocks radiated from one central core.
The novel architecture of the building was specific to its purpose.
Perfect seclusion required that each 8-by-12-foot cell be equipped with running water, a flush toilet, and central heating, amenities even President Andrew Jackson did not yet have in the White House.
Each cell was lit by a skylight and a barred door leading to a tiny walled yard.
Meals were delivered through a slot in the wall.
Only one book was permitted--the Bible.
Prisoners were permitted to pass the time making shoes or weaving baskets, and were allowed into their yard for one hour a day.
They were never to see or speak to each other.
Whatever the length of their sentence, they would serve their time at Eastern alone.
Voice: Separate confinement is intended to furnish the criminal with every opportunity for promoting his restoration to the path of virtue because seclusion is an essential ingredient in moral treatment.
Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons.
[Roberts Vaux] Betts: I mean, they say solitary was for you to repent, but one of the questions is, like, how and what are the mechanisms?
And If you leave somebody in absolute silence and you haven't been equipped to deal with your mind, I don't think that that's gonna be effective.
[Heavy scraping] [Keys jingling] ♪ Rahsaan Thomas: When you first get to the hole, I think that was the hardest time I've ever done, even though it's the safest 'cause you're in solitary, you're by yourself.
But there was absolutely nothing for my mind to do.
I swear to God, one hour felt like 6 days.
I would keep asking, "What time is it?"
And the time would not move, right?
It was just the most boring thing to be stuck with your thoughts, just be stuck having to face yourself.
No distractions, no nothing.
It's a form of torture.
It's like dropping water on your head.
It seems like it wouldn't hurt, but it's torturous.
You end up being released worse than you went in.
Austin Reed Details His Experiences in Auburn Prison
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 9m 40s | Austin Reed recounts his experiences over two decades of being incarcerated in Auburn Prison. (9m 40s)
Elam Lynds Reforms the Auburn Prison System
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 2m 21s | The new head guard at Auburn Prison establishes a new strict regimen of efficiency and order. (2m 21s)
The House of Refuge and Juvenile Detention
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 3m 58s | The House of Refuge is the nation's first institution for the reformation of juvenile delinquents. (3m 58s)
The Largest Mass Hanging in American History
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 4m 26s | President Abraham Lincoln sentences 38 Native Americans to death for attacks against settlers. (4m 26s)
Levi Ames and the Spectacle of Public Execution
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 2m 45s | There has always been a fascination with those that commit crimes and how they're punished for them. (2m 45s)
The Myths and Fascination with the Outlaw Jesse James
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 13m 42s | During the Reconstruction Era, an outlaw captures the public's attention: Jesse James. (13m 42s)
What Does It Mean to be Accountable?
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 10m 11s | When a crime is committed, should we look to punish or to move forward toward healing? (10m 11s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...























